Correlation of ESG Scores From Different Providers [One More Chart]

Recently came across the below chart, which illustrates the weak correlation in company-specific ESG ratings from different providers (which I wrote about earlier this week). Even though the below uses slightly different data sets than my previous post, the R² is remarkably similar. I’ve heard other experts reference correlations in .3 to .4 range, which seems consistent with the below and my previous post. I believe the takeaway is the same: the scores are directionally similar (the below dots generally move from bottom left to upper right), but the correlation is relatively loose.

source: Sustainable Brands (via https://www.slideshare.net/sustainablebrands/rising-waves-the-second-generation-of-esg-metrics-and-a-movement-toward-bringing-dark-data-to-light)